Best Non-stick Pizza Peel in 2021 – Easy Pizza Handling

AamanoPizza.com content is free. When you make a purchase through referral links on our site, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you.


Nobody wants to ruin their pizza when trying to transfer the dough from the counter into your oven or when taking the freshly-baked pizza out. So, you went to your local store to purchase one of those pizza peels on the shelves, only to find out that the one you got does a terrible job – it sticks and is pretty tricky to use.

So, if you hate your sticky pizza peel and want a non-stick model, then you’ve come to the right place.

In this post, we’ve whipped up the top 5 best non-stick pizza peels on the market. Plus, we included a detailed buying guide to ensure you make an informed decision.

Best Non-stick Pizza Peels – Comparison

Picture Product Name Material Weight Price
Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Composite Resin 2 pounds Check Latest Price
Pizza Peel 18-inch By Q’s INN Pizza Peel 18-inch By Q’s INN Aluminum 1.2 Pounds Check Latest Price
The Ultimate Pizza Peel The Ultimate Pizza Peel Wood/Ceramic 1.32 pounds Check Latest Price
Silvergent Pizza Peel Silvergent Pizza Peel Stainless Steel 2.07 pounds Check Latest Price
Non-stick Pizza for Pizza Stone Non-stick Pizza for Pizza Stone Metal 1.54 pounds Check Latest Price

What is the Benefit of Using a Non-stick Pizza Peel?

The pizza peel is an essential tool to make your baking experience a splendid one. They are designed to allow you to transfer your dough from your counter to the oven and safely retrieve it from the hot oven.

While every model out there can do that, a non-stick pizza peel is designed to slide under your uncooked pizza effortlessly and get off the blade with ease. With this version, you may not need to sprinkle flour on the blade to get a decent food release performance.

Things to Consider When Shopping for a Non-stick Pizza Peel

When trying to pinpoint the right pizza peel, you need to pay attention to the following factors discussed in this section.

Materials

Pizza peels come in different materials, and the most common option is the wooden pizza peel. However, there are other material options, such as stainless steel and aluminum.

Wood

This is an excellent material option, especially if you’re not looking to spend a fortune on a peel. However, not all wooden pizza peels live up to the expectations. Thus, it’s best to stick with a material that can withstand extreme temperatures and enough the right amount of support to your food.

For this task, we recommend bamboo material. Sadly, the downside to these wooden models is the maintenance. Regardless of the type of wood, you have to treat them with extra care and caution.

Metal

For metallic pizza peels, there are two options: stainless steel and aluminum. The metallic peels are built to last almost a lifetime. They are hassle-free to maintain and effortless to clean.

That’s not why most people consider them a better option; metallic options are usually thinner than wooden peels. Their thin peels allow them to slide underneath the pizza with ease. Unfortunately, you will have to deal with your dough sticking to the peel.

Composite material

Another common material for pizza peel is the composite material, a combination of wood and resins. The best thing about this blend of materials is that it enhances the wood strength and eliminates any work about your peel flaking.
In addition, composite pizza peels feature a thinner construction, which means you should have no issue sliding these models under your pizza. Sadly, composite peels come with shorter handles. Thus, making them suitable for low volume operators or people baking on a grill or a small oven.

Handle Length

When it comes to the handle length, you need to put the depth of your oven into consideration. The best pizza peel for you is one with a blade that reaches the back of your deck oven while your hands are kept at bay from the hot oven.

In general, you want a long handle to let you handle your pizza at a safe distance to prevent accidental burns. Also, it comes in handy for reaching the far end of your oven with ease.

Shape and Size of the blade

This is another essential factor to consider since the pizza will be sitting on the peel’s blade. The blade is available in two shape options:- rectangular and round. Keep in mind that the shape and size of the blade determine the size of pizza you can handle without a sweat.

In general, round-shaped peels are best for turning your pizzas in the oven, while the rectangular versions are ideal for cooking wide pizzas or prefer a much larger platform.

Best Nonstick Pizza Peel Reviews

1. Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Pizza Peel

Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Pizza Peel

If you need a peel to pick up your pizza from the oven and prep the surface without a sweat, the Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Pizza Peel can be your best bet. This model is made of composite that holds pretty impressively. It features a non-stick pastry cloth to guarantee an excellent food release performance.

The Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Pizza Peel features a smooth and sturdy construction that allows you to pick your large pizzas without creating a mess. This best non-stick pizza peel is our top recommendation for seasoned bakers and novices looking to take their baking skills to the next level.

In addition, this model does not split or warp like the wooden model. And even better, you can toss this peel into your dishwasher for a convenient cleaning experience. Aside from its naturally low-friction blade surface, the xo Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Pizza Peel features the brand’s patented sliding conveyor technology to allow you to pick up and transfer pie crust, artisan bread, and many more with ease.

Strengths:

  • It’s totally dishwasher safe
  • Easy and goof-proof food transfer and release performance
  • Low maintenance
  • Rectangular blade shape for large pizzas

Weaknesses:

  • On the pricey side
  • The cover shrinks after a couple of washing

2. Pizza Peel 12×14 with 18-inch By Q’s INN.

Pizza Peel 12x14 with 18-inch Woden Detachable Handle

The Q’s INN Pizza Peel comes with a unique extra long, detachable wood handle to allow you to handle the pizza in the hot oven from a safe distance. Another benefit of the detachable design is ensuring smart storage in small cabinets when not in use. Also, you can remove the handle and use the peel to shape your pizza on the countertop.

In addition, the handle is made of wood, which offers safe handling and a comfortable grip. The Q’s INN Pizza Peel is built for both home and professional use. It features a rounded aluminum blade to slide underneath the pizza conveniently.

What’s more? This unit can be easily cleaned, and the detachable comes in handy as a rolling pin. No wonder it’s a top choice for many users.

On the downside, this model is not dishwasher safe, which means you’ve to hand wash to clean the peel. Also, the metal blade is not scratch-resistant and, with time, might look rough and old.

Strengths:

  • Extra-long 18-inch handle with a comfortable grip
  • Detachable wood handle for easy storage and versatility
  • Easy to clean
  • Suitable for home and professional use

Weaknesses:

  • It’s not dishwasher safe
  • Unattractive design
  • It tends to scratch easily

3. The Ultimate Aluminum Pizza Peel. 14-inch Paddle

The Ultimate Aluminum Pizza Peel. 14-inch Paddle

If you want a convenient way of getting your pizza, bread, etc., in and out of the oven, The Ultimate Aluminum Pizza Peel. 14-inch Paddle might just be what you’re looking for. It rocks an advanced design to eliminate any worries about the dough sticking to the peel or falling off when handling the pizza.

This unit is a decent choice for those looking for a better alternative to wooden or metal pizza peel models. Its paddle features aluminum construction that boasts easy cleaning, maintenance, and handling without altering the taste of your food.

On top of that, the paddle features a non-stick, nano-ceramic coating to deliver excellent food release performance. Unlike wood or metal peels, The Ultimate Aluminum Pizza Peel 14 inch Paddle does not require excessive flour to guarantee the easy release of the raw dough onto the stone.

Talking about its design, the peel features a back lip to prevent your pizza from slipping and keep your cooked pie in place. Also, this feature makes it easier to slide the dough or perfectly cooked pie off. It comes with a 10-inch hardwood handle to keep you at a safe distance from extremely hot oven openings.

Strengths:

  • 60-day money-back guarantee
  • Stylish, elegant design
  • 10-inch hardwood handle for safe handling
  • Nonstick aluminum paddle

Weaknesses:

  • Cleaning this pizza can be exhausting due to its design

4. Silvergent Pizza Peel with Non-Stick Stainless Steel Paddle

Silvergent Pizza Peel with Non-Stick Stainless Steel Paddle

The Silvergent Pizza Peel offers excellent value for the money. This model features a slim design and sturdy stainless steel construction that assures long time durability. It features a non-stick coating to ensure your pie slides effortlessly to and from the oven or stone.

Unlike wooden peels that are difficult to slide under the pizza crust and quite heavy to handle, the Silvergent Pizza Peel is lightweight and dishwasher safe for an easy cleaning experience. Furthermore, it comes with an ergonomic grip to make it easier for both occasional or professional chefs to lift pizzas, bread, etc., a breeze.

The Silvergent Pizza Peel is large enough to handle medium-sized pizzas and comes at a reasonable length to allow you to place your pies at the back of the oven while keeping your body from the hot oven. Its non-stick paddle delivers a smooth experience. Above all, this product comes with a pizza cutter for slicing your food instantly.

Strengths:

  • FDA grade stainless steel construction
  • Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
  • Comfortable Softgrip handle
  • Foldable handle for smart storage

Weaknesses:

  • Poor quality control

5. Pizza Peel, Non-stick Pizza Paddle for Pizza Stone

Pizza Peel, Non-stick Pizza Paddle for Pizza Stone

Earning a spot on our list is the MOREWELL Pizza Peel comes with an aluminum head, making the product lightweight and easy to slide underneath the pizza base. The light aluminum metal surface features an oxidation coating to deliver an impressive non-stick experience.

On top of that, it comes with a foldable wooden handle for easy storage and easy maneuvering. This unit is an excellent peel for both novices and experienced cooks. This kitchen tool is perfect for transferring delicate bread, pastries, cakes, pizza into your wood-fired oven or on your grill.

That’s not the best thing about the MOREWELL Pizza Peel; it’s extremely durable and effortless to clean. Its construction features food-grade aluminum, which means you don’t have to bother about bacteria, fungus, and mold growing on your paddle.

Strengths:

  • Easy to store
  • Lightweight design for easy handling
  • food-grade aluminum to prevent bacterial, mold, and fungus growth
  • Sturdy and durable construction

Weaknesses:

  • The handle can be too short for some bakers

Frequently Asked Questions and Answered

How do I prep my pizza peel to prevent the dough from sticking?

It’s best to purchase a non-stick pizza peel or a perforated metal version to save you from stress. However, if you are using a wooden or metallic peel, there’s a way around it. You can sprinkle some cornmeal or flour on the peel before placing the dough on it to help reduce the stickiness.

Can I slice my pizza on the non-stick peel?

Wooden paddles offer a knife-friendly surface that allows you to slice your pizza on them. However, metal peels might be a bad idea as they tend to scratch easily and may be harsh on your knife’s edge.

How can I increase your non-stick pizza peel life?

  • Follow the manual carefully
  • Do not soak for a long time
  • Dishwasher or hand wash as instructed
  • Stay away from abrasive cleaners
  • Never leave the peel inside the over for a prolonged period

Conclusion

In our opinion, the Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Pizza Peel is our top choice – and for several good reasons. It’s come at a modest price and features heavy-duty aluminum construction, making this favorite durable and effortless to clean.

Also, it has a lightweight design that makes it handling hassle-free. Even better, it has a foldable wooden handle for easy storage and incredible portability. More so, the Exo Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Pizza Peel is dishwasher-friendly for an easy cleanup experience.

But regardless of your choice, we are confident that any of the products reviewed on this list will serve your purpose.

Related Resources: