Pizza Screen vs. Pizza Stone – Which One Is Better?

AamanoPizza.com content is free. When you make a purchase through referral links on our site, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you.


Between pizza screen and pizza stone, I would prefer pizza stone. Because pizza stone is reliable, easy to clean, and can spread heat all over the crust at a slow speed, which is the ideal cooking environment for a crispy mouth-watering pizza.

The difference between the pizza screen and the pizza stone is not a big deal, but if you are a newbie, you will face a problem selecting your desired pizza accessories.

So let us enlighten you with this knowledge; we will discuss

  • Difference between pizza screen vs. pizza stone
  • Which is better, pizza screen or pizza stone
  • Should you choose pizza screen or pizza stone

The Difference Between Pizza Screen and Pizza Stone

The main difference between the pizza screen and the pizza stone is the materials. Pizza screens are made from aluminum; on the other hand, pizza stones are crafted from ceramic or clay.

As pizza stones are made from clay or ceramic, they can be given any shape and size.

But pizza stones are found in two different shapes, one is round, and the other is rectangular. These pizza stones have a flat surface, and they are best for distributing heat equally all over the pizza stone that helps your pizza obtain a crispy crust. Also, as a result, you get a well-cooked pizza through this pizza stone, but it takes a reasonable amount of time to cook.

On the other hand, the pizza screen doesn’t have any flat surface; it has a mashed surface with an aluminum ring attached to the side. Their weight is less compared to the pizza stones; this helps to arrange them perfectly. These mashed surface doesn’t distribute heat, but they allow the full heat of the oven to pass through the pizza crust, making it crispy. The pizza screen takes less time to cook the pizza, which makes it more convenient.

Which is Better, Pizza screen or Pizza stone?

Well, both of these works as a tray where you put the pizza dough. As they are different in size, materials, and shapes, they have specific pros and cons of their own. Each one has its specialty, so telling one is better than another is not an easy task. So let us talk about their pros and cons, by comparing them, we should come to a better conclusion.

Pizza Stone

Best Pizza Stone for Charcoal Grill

Let’s see the pros and cons of a pizza stone,

Pros:

  • Ceramic or clay can take high heat, so pizza stones are suitable for any high or low heat oven
  • The various size makes it versatile, the minimum length is 8 inches, and the maximum length of pizza stone is 16 inches
  • Flat surface or mashed surface, all kinds of styles can be applied to a pizza stone
  • The heat flow is perfect; it’s pretty capable of distributing heat all over the pizza dough
  • It is not sticky, so putting the dough or taking it out of the pan is easy.
  • Pizza stones are heavy, but washing them is less painful.

Cons:

  • A pizza stone is crafted from high-grade materials that take a lot of time to heat up. So in terms of cooking pizza, you will have to preheat your micro oven or other types of the pizza oven.

Pizza screen

We know the pros and cons of the pizza stone; let’s take a look at the pizza screen pros and cons.

Pros:

  • A mashed surface helps to flow heat and air into the pizza crust
  • They are made from aluminum, which makes them lightweight
  • Maintaining these pizza screens is easy; you can store them in small places
  • they also can absorb high heat, so no need to worry about heat problem
  • pizza screen doesn’t require you to preheat your oven, and it helps to cook pizza in a short time

Cons:

  • The pizza screen has a thick surface to cook thick pizza, but when you put heavy pizza, you will face a problem putting it in or taking it out of the oven.

Should you Choose a Pizza stone or a Pizza screen?

Judging by the pros and cons and their capability, we are sure you have made up your mind. But before you buy a pizza stone or a pizza screen, you should check the possible outcome. Will it be able to perform as you want it to be or what you want to do with it? What kind of pizza do you want? It would be best if you considered all of these points. So let us help you to choose. Now we will point out the possible outcome of the pizza stone and pizza screen.

Choose pizza stone if you want-

  • well-backed pizza with a perfect crust
  • easy to clean and non-sticky surface
  • capable of distributing heat equally
  • able to handle all types of pizza
  • if you want it to retain the heat for a long time

Choose a pizza screen if you want-

  • suitable for thick pizza with a crispy crust
  • It takes a short time to cook pizza
  • doesn’t require preheating the oven
  • lightweight and easy to maintain
  • made from high heat-absorbing materials

These will help you choose your desired pizza pan; besides these points, you need to decide what type of pizza pan you would like to have.

Final Verdict

We have shared all the detailed information on pizza screen vs. pizza stone. We have also shared the pros and cons of a pizza stone and pizza screen that will be helpful for you to understand and choose your pizza screen and stone. However, the rest is up to you because the priority of your desire comes first, and you will buy the pizza screen and stone. It will be best if you make your mind based on your need.